Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

**Shin Hye** · 11-30-2007 04:17 PM

[Image: th_03328_BoA-Charice-Pempengco-1_122_187lo.jpg]

Who is the better singer, Asian pop idol BoA or the young Filipina singer Charice Pempengco? BoA was discovered at the age of 11, and released her debut album after two years of training. When she was only 12 years old, Charmaine Clarice Relucio Pempengco won the third place on the first season of a singing contest called Little Big Star in 2005. Both are talented young singers. Who do you think is the better singer at a young age?

Charice Pempengco Sings " And I Am telling You Im Not Going"

Charice sings A whole new world with a suju member Kyu Hyun

Boa sings A whole new wrorl with Tvxq member Xian Junsu

Source: Asianbite

**4jpz** · 12-01-2007 02:50 AM

I like Charise's version better. Her voice quality is superb and her performance is amazing!!! Well, they do have different voice quality but then again I might be biased because I'm Filipino... lol...

Kidding aside, the A Whole New World sang by Charise and KyuHyun has a better quality in terms of voice and diction and to think it's just a performance in a studio whereas the one with BoA and JunSu was in an event but it didn't really catch my attention that much!

sorry BoA fans!

Added on edit:
oh... shin hye I don't think the links work... I always got an error whe I clicked them. Maybe it's my connection... anyways, I have to search for another BoA vid just to make a comparison... I have Charise performance on file so that's no problem for me...

VIERAN · 12-01-2007 02:59 PM

charise has this natural golden voice and she didn't attend such training. her voice is really amazing and i saw her at all times in our television contest she's small, a child but mature voice diva. that's all i can say.

**Krazoom** · 12-01-2007 03:33 PM

Definitely Charice has a better voice but as a performer I'd say BoA.. BoA will still always be #1 to me anyways..

saranghaeyo · 04-24-2008 07:41 PM

OMG.Charice is realllyyy that good since she's already been compared to an international pop artist? WHOAA. Honestly, I never liked her in the LBS competition,but look at her now, its just WOW.

shinmaum · 04-24-2008 07:59 PM

Charice is probably better....I love this girl's voice,,And you can really get into her music, Love Her..;p

cute_angel0858 · 04-29-2008 02:09 PM

i'll go for charice!!!!!!!!

wholan · 05-03-2008 04:22 PM

of course BoA is better than Charice, Charice I don't even know her

aiaismiley · 05-04-2008 11:06 AM

woww charice is REALLY good! haha but i think that BoA is prettier and is better even though Charice is good too. Charice will definately grow up to be a great singer. but the problem is, Bianca Ryan sings just as well as Charice and she even won America's Got Talent, but she only has one CD and i havent heard of Bianca Ryan for like a year or two years

eilyn · 09-14-2008 01:31 PM

charise is a natural singer, boa on the other hand is a performer... i remember charise having duet with lea salonga in one of her concert at the Philippines. she really can sing! now with celine dion. hope she soars higher. we do have lots of talented singer in the past like banig, but where are they now?...